Post by TheMainEvent on Jul 31, 2010 18:38:40 GMT -5
I am giving my unbiased views of the divisions as a whole based on a 5 star system evaluating each team. For UNKNOWN players I am giving an automatic 3 stars & a question mark to show I'm not sure. I will also total the stars for each division to see who has the highest total.
AFC 50
AFC EAST11 Buffalo Bills-qpeezy ? Miami Dolphins - Cpiroli New England Patriots - Germeh New York Jets - Boerny
AFC North 12 Baltimore Ravens - Lock_Down_ Cincinatti Bengals - FatboybobPSN Cleveland Browns - jstraus7205 Pittsburgh Steelers - Xdog30
AFC South 13 Houston Texans - Grizzley Indianapolis Colts - A_nimrod ? Jacksonville Jaguars - TheCooLx Tennesee Titans - Locdawg
AFC West14 Denver Broncos - Spyder_ Kansas City Chiefs - TheMainEvent Oakland Raiders - Xgunrage ? San Diego Chargers -Antec ?
NFC 54
NFC East14 Dallas Cowboys - CeeGee New York Giants- Frythatchicken Philadelphia Eagles - Evans426 Washington Redskins - Expertise ?
NFC North14 Chicago Bears - Deepthreat Detroit Lions - Wopsurprise Green Bay Packers - Broncobobby Minnesota Vikings - Nikov10
NFC South 12 Atlanta Falcons - JoeBush Carolina Panther s- redsoxfan New Orleans Saints - KRC Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Massimo ?
NFC West14 Arizona Cardinals - JoeSchroduh San Francisco 49ers - MrAmazing74 Seattle Seahawks - Xliqx St. Louis Rams - xCRUFFx
i am open to debate and change as I am by far not perfect and my memories of PLAYERS (not just based on how they did as a whole with their team, but think how good they are as a player because some good players had some bad teams)
Last Edit: Jul 31, 2010 23:06:12 GMT -5 by TheMainEvent
VNFL: Kansas City Chiefs Season 1: 7-9 Season 2: 11-5 Season 3: 8-8 Season 4: 10-6 Season 5: 9-7 Season 6: 9-7
bush 2 star no hard feelings and i know you had the browns
mramazing 2star
those are the changes i would make basedon madden 10 and from what i remember
after thinking it over and talking with u im changing broncobobby and amazing. i say bush is a 2.5, i round up all the .5's. and im not changing any of the question marks as they have to have played in the league to be evaluated, even if you expect big things; we've seen allot of hype go bad for some players who join the league
VNFL: Kansas City Chiefs Season 1: 7-9 Season 2: 11-5 Season 3: 8-8 Season 4: 10-6 Season 5: 9-7 Season 6: 9-7
Post by frythatchicken on Jul 31, 2010 19:07:06 GMT -5
This is pretty cool... I think things like this are great for the league. However, I think owner input should be used to determine such a ratings list. For example, there are several players in tough leagues with good owners that play a high brand of football but may fall short in games that could go either way. Things such as this can only be evaluated or considered based on input from league owners. I understand having a 1 star rating but I would bet if you asked anyone who played me, including yourself, it wasn't a one star performance...I just think each owner should have input to vote at least within their own league... NFC east gets like 7 stars per coach to distribute but they can only grant a half star to their onw team and the rest must be cast within their league... and this allows everyone to have a stake in determining the outcome of such a list...Just my thoughts.
This is pretty cool... I think things like this are great for the league. However, I think owner input should be used to determine such a ratings list. For example, there are several players in tough leagues with good owners that play a high brand of football but may fall short in games that could go either way. Things such as this can only be evaluated or considered based on input from league owners. I understand having a 1 star rating but I would bet if you asked anyone who played me, including yourself, it wasn't a one star performance...I just think each owner should have input to vote at least within their own league... NFC east gets like 7 stars per coach to distribute but they can only grant a half star to their onw team and the rest must be cast within their league... and this allows everyone to have a stake in determining the outcome of such a list...Just my thoughts.
if you read the post it states that i am very open to input and know i wont be 100% correct but am open to input and change as I've already done based on a persons views. I did this for fun, not to get a big mass vote to decide actual rankings, its just a fun thing to look at and make comparisons with as we go into the new season. And I love ya fry, but I rate you a 1, you may put up some good fights with players but if you don't produce you don't produce.
Last Edit: Jul 31, 2010 19:13:51 GMT -5 by TheMainEvent
VNFL: Kansas City Chiefs Season 1: 7-9 Season 2: 11-5 Season 3: 8-8 Season 4: 10-6 Season 5: 9-7 Season 6: 9-7